Six Things a Restaurateur Keeps in Her Pantry This Month

  1. Olive oil. Ours is always extra-virgin Italian, with the brand rotating depending on what we can reasonably import for the restaurant, with all of the new tariffs and sky-high shipping costs. But solid options can also be found at Costco or Whole Foods. At Sale Pepe, we feature our olive oil with focaccia gonfia. At home, we use our liquid gold to finish roasted butternut squash or sweet potatoes. But honestly, there is not much we don’t pour it over to finish any given meal on any given night.

  2. Parmigiano Reggiano. A little block always lives in our fridge at home, but I am counting it as pantry anyway. We import whole wheels of the stuff for the restaurant because it finishes almost every single pasta dish and many of our pizzas. The nubs also get dropped into soups and sauces for umami. At home, for breakfast, it is perfect dusted into scrambled eggs.

  3. Bread. It is not a humble-brag but a simple fact that we are lucky enough to have access to the bread we bake at the restaurant every morning and that my husband’s passion for the stuff means he is often baking and experimenting with different kinds of bread at home. There are more loaves in the freezer than meat. But, if we did not have an Italian chef in our kitchen, I would still want to take the time to bake my bread at home. Nothing beats it. For us, hearty slices dropped on the table signal the beginning of a meal, sometimes before the table is even fully set. We use old bread to make breadcrumbs and panzanella and ribollita and croutons for salad and stuffing in November.

  4. Anchovies. These little guys aren’t for everyone, so at the restaurant we make sure to that they are pretty obvious, draping them over burrata and pizza. At home, they are more ubiquitous and we use them to amp up salad dressings and even add them to my favorite burger recipe. But the best way to use anchovies at home is in my all-time favorite pantry pasta, spaghetti aglio olio.

  5. Sardines, or tuna. A tin or two are always in the cupboard and live right next to the anchovies, but for a different effect. We plate whole pieces of sardines with pickled veggies, salumi and cheese with aperitivo on any given Sunday or to start holiday meals like Thanksgiving. Italian tuna is a good stand- in, too. For an elevated take on the tuna and crackers that I used to enjoy as a kid, we toss ours with celery, capers, a little shallot, parsley, olive oil and lemon zest. This also makes for a fast lunch on busy days, tossed with farro.

  6. Vinegar. Three stay in rotation: rice wine, red wine and balsamic. The red and balsamic dress our daily salads at home. Red wine vinegar reduction is critical for a decent caponata. The balsamic is reduced into a glaze on our butternut squash and pancetta pizza at Sale Pepe. The red and rice wine vinegars are also great for quick pickles, perfect for leftover turkey sandwiches at this time of the year.

Come Si Fa: On the night after Thanksgiving, when you cannot even look at another leftover, pull your olive oil, anchovies and a slice of old bread out of your pantry. Get a head of garlic and a box of spaghetti. Warm the oil and gently melt two anchovies into it with the sliced garlic. Toss with spaghetti, a splash of pasta water and sprinkle of red pepper flakes to finish. Top with breadcrumbs toasted from the old bread.


Everything linked here is on my own shelf. A few links earn CYA a small commission, which keeps the pantry stocked and the writing going. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Next
Next

Who Columbus Day Was Really For (Or, How You Find Out it Began as an Answer to a Massacre.)